Scott Atran

Co-founder, Artis International

Scott Atran is co-founder of Artis International and emeritus director of research at France’s National Center for Scientific Research; he also holds research positions at the University of Oxford and University of Michigan, and is a member of the US National Academy of Sciences. He is the author of Talking to the Enemy (2010) and In Gods We Trust (2002).

Written by Scott Atran

Recent Comments

ISIS is a revolution

Scott Atran

Arun Ezhutadhan writes:

Every single Revolutionary movement- even purely chauvinistic and national ones, e.g. De Valera’s- has had an impact on my obscure and provincial corner of the world. This gives me a vantage point quite different from that of the Olympian, or Eurocentric, public intellectual who can glibly tells us things like this- ‘At that time, (the so called ‘Axial Age’) large-scale civilisations arose under the watchful gaze of powerful divinities, who mercilessly punished moral transgressors – thus ensuring that even strangers in multiethnic empires would work and fight as one.’

Is there any truth to this notion? None at all. The best elaborated Axial Age politi...

READ MORE→ See comment

Belief in supernatural beings is totally natural – and false

Scott Atran

Core beliefs in supernatural agents aren’t so much false as absurd. they involve “category mistakes” in the sene of Aristotle (Sommers and Papa), violating constraints on universal semantic structures/ For example, God is a sentient (much less omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent) being but bodiless isn’t false but absurd, like a four-footed idea. Literally “incomprehensible” as Galileo noted in his letters to his daughter, as Hobbes pointed out in Leviathan, and “preposterous” as the religious votary Kierkegaard stressed. One could not learn a language if one believed that the semantic relationships violated in such pseudo-propositions were in fact valid (see Frank Keil and Sheila Wla...

READ MORE→ See comment

Should we rename institutions that honour dead racists?

Scott Atran

And inclide Socrates, Plato and Aristotle as well?

→ See comment