Get curated editors’ picks, peeks behind the scenes, film recommendations and more.
Can we learn anything about what makes a raven by looking only at apples? The German-born logician Carl Gustav Hempel (1905-97) thought that, using the inductive logic that scientists rely on to prove or disprove hypotheses, you ought to be able to – but in such a way that clashes mightily with human intuition. This peculiar ripple in reasoning, which became known as ‘the raven paradox’ due to the example Hempel used to elucidate it, goes as follows:
1. All ravens are black
2. If something is not black it is not a raven
3. The fact that my pet raven is black supports the hypothesis that all ravens are black
4. The fact that my apple is red also supports the hypothesis that all ravens are black
The sequence appears to break down somewhere between the third and fourth claims. And yet, upon examination, inductive logic tells us that claim four does indeed follow. In this brief animation, Marc Lange, a professor of philosophy at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, dissects why Hempel’s claim seems to hold to reason, even as it cuts against our intuitions in a way that seems unresolvable.
Video by Wireless Philosophy
Thinkers and theories
Bernard Williams on Descartes’s audacious endeavour to prove knowledge is possible
Ageing and death
When his elderly parents make a suicide pact, Doron struggles to accept their choice
Yes, the Inuit have dozens of words for snow – but what does each one mean exactly?
History of science
How one of history’s most beautiful books was used to find fate in the cosmos
Symmetry rules life on Earth – but it comes with many fascinating exceptions
Human rights and justice
Beyond ‘guilty’ or ‘not guilty’ – could a range of verdict options be more just?
Is the question ‘Why is there something instead of nothing?’ even worth asking?
Logic and probability
Is it more likely you’re a person with a past, or an ephemeral brain in a void?
Ageing and death
‘It’s not beautiful, but it’s interesting’ – an ageing nude model surveys her body