Get curated editors’ picks, peeks behind the scenes, film recommendations and more.
For centuries, philosophers – and more recently, science-fiction writers – have been concocting riffs and variations on a particular thought experiment: if every bit of your body could be perfectly scanned and replicated, in what ways would the replica still be ‘you’? In this interview from the PBS series Closer to Truth, Andy Clark, a professor of philosophy at the University of Edinburgh, dissects a version of this experiment posed by the US philosopher Daniel Dennett, in which a body is scanned, destroyed, and replicated in a distant place. While science hasn’t yet brought us close to putting Dennett’s conundrum to the test, we can still grapple with the intriguing and perhaps troubling metaphysical questions it raises, questions that might become even more material as we careen further into the information age, including: would ‘you’ be dead, or would your sense of self perpetuate in the copy? And, if you were recreated several times, where exactly might you expect to find your embodied sense of self?
Video by Closer to Truth
Film and visual culture
At the movies with Pauline Kael – in the arthouse cinema where she got her start
Mood and emotion
‘Let me dream you into my reality’: memories illuminate an unthinkable isolation
Wesley wants to solve the rooftop mystery – but does he have what it takes?
History of ideas
Tantra is, and was, a subversive philosophy of feminine power
Ancient Greek sculptures were colourful. Why does the white marble ideal persist?
Love and friendship
Skiing blind is a challenge – but it helps to have a loved one to guide you
Thinkers and theories
Metaphysics and beyond – Martha Nussbaum on Aristotle’s indelible ideas
A massive art installation attempts to put the COVID-19 deaths in perspective
Dizzying discs and obscene wordplay – revisiting Marcel Duchamp’s 1926 film debut